Cerattepe court case stalled after request for judge’s recusal
Residents of Artvin, a small town in the North-eastern Black Sea region in Turkey continue to resist the opening of a dangerous gold and copper mine in the Cerattepe area for more than 20 years. After years of resistance, several mining companies, and several court rulings against the project, the conflict is still ongoing. [See Background note below—HIC-HLRN]
The controversial Cerattepe case has been stalled after lawyers from the anti-government Green Artvin Association demanded recusal, claiming that the judges are not fair.
The latest hearing in the case took place yesterday in Rize province. Amid tight security measures due to fears that protestors could create chaos in front of the courthouse, lawyers from the Eti Bakır Company that wants to extract copper mine in the Cerattepe region of northeastern Artvin province and the Green Artvin Association defended them for the last time in the case.
After hours-long debates, the lawyers from the association left the courthouse, demanding recusation. Speaking in front of the courthouse, Bedrettin Kalın said the case will not be settled unless all plaintiffs are allowed in the court.
Some locals in Artvin, guided by the association, were against the opening of the mine site. In 2013, the association filed a lawsuit for the cancellation of the environmental impact assessment that had been previously approved. The court said the company that wanted to build on the site still had to make some arrangements in the project.
In line with the court`s decision, the company made the necessary improvements in the project in cooperation with 12 engineers. The new environmental impact assessment was approved by the court in June 2015.
Despite that, the Green Artvin Association again quickly filed a lawsuit for the cancellation of this assessment as well.
Photo: Locals protest Cerattepe mining efforts in Turkey’s northeast. Source:
Turkey Islamic Justice and Development blogspot.
See video report of local protests
See related article: Turkey: Villagers Confront Black Sea Region Mine
The first attempts to mine the gold and copper in the area started in the beginning of 1980s. After several years of explorations, the first mining license was given in 1987. In the early 1990s, the license was transferred to the international mining company, Cominco, which started further explorations and test drillings. Even after the test drillings, the negative effects were observed immediately when livestock died suddenly. At that point, residents (who were thinking of the mine as a new income and employment source) started to reconsider the mine in the area as a threat.
Since 1995, a resistance movement started to be organised under the newly founded Green Artvin Association. In 1998, a petition with more than 10.000 signatures was delivered to the ministry of environment, which in turn halted the project for re-investigation. Unable to start mining due to local opposition, Cominco left the mine in 2004 and transferred the license to INMET Mining, who tried to re-start the project. However, the Green Artvin Association and lawyers from Artvin Bar took the project to the court, which ended in 2009 with a cancellation of the previous mining license.
However, in 2012, a new mining license was issued by the government, and Cengiz Holding (under the roof of Ozaltin Insaat) who filed a EIA request and get a positive report soon after. In January 2015, Rize Administrative Court overruled the project’s positive EIA report. However, with an outstanding rush and within very short time, the mining company has received another positive EIA report despite the court ruling, giving right to a renewed permit to mine in the area, with supposedly newer technologies.
Another complaint prepared by 61 lawyers has been filed in July 2015, with the signature of 751 people, making it the most extensive environmental court case in Turkey’s history. Since July 2015, people of Artvin have reacted to the advances by the company, and started to keep a continuous watch by barricading the road leading to the planned area.
The protests have enlisted nationwide support from several local and national NGOs The mining project threatens one of the most important nature-conservation sites in Turkey, where all of Artvin’s drinking water comes from. Just next the mine site, there is Hatila National Park, and Kafkasör Tourism Conservation and Development area under it. The area hosts 2,000 plant forms, 124 endemic forms, hundreds of animal forms.